Smart Forfour common problems and reliability issues
Honest rundown of the most common Smart Forfour faults, what to watch for, and how to keep one running well.

The Smart Forfour is known for several common issues that can affect its reliability and performance. These problems often relate to the electrical system, engine, transmission, suspension, and brakes. Understanding these faults can help potential buyers make informed decisions.
Electrical System Issues
One of the most frequently reported problems with the Smart Forfour involves its electrical system. Owners have experienced issues with the battery, alternator, and various electronic components. Faulty wiring can lead to intermittent electrical failures, affecting everything from the lights to the infotainment system.
The battery can sometimes drain unexpectedly, leaving drivers stranded. Regular checks and maintenance can help mitigate these issues, but it is advisable to be cautious of any electrical warning lights on the dashboard. Additionally, the alternator may fail, leading to further electrical problems if not addressed promptly.
Engine Problems
The Smart Forfour’s engine has been known to exhibit a range of issues, particularly with the petrol variant. Common complaints include excessive oil consumption and problems with the timing chain. These issues can lead to significant engine damage if not monitored closely.
Regular oil changes are essential to prevent excessive consumption, and owners should keep an eye on oil levels between services. Timing chain problems can result in costly repairs, so it is wise to listen for unusual noises from the engine that may indicate a failing chain.
Transmission Faults
Transmission issues are another common concern for Smart Forfour owners, particularly with the automated manual transmission (AMT). Drivers have reported problems with gear changes, including hesitation or rough shifting. These faults can affect the overall driving experience and may lead to more severe transmission damage.
Regular maintenance is crucial for the AMT system, including software updates and fluid changes. If you notice any unusual behaviour during gear changes, it is advisable to have the system checked by a qualified technician to avoid further complications.
Suspension Problems
The suspension system of the Smart Forfour can also present issues, particularly with the shock absorbers and springs. Many owners have reported a bumpy ride or excessive noise when driving over bumps, which can indicate worn components. This can affect the vehicle’s handling and comfort.
Regular inspections of the suspension system can help identify worn parts before they lead to more significant problems. If you notice any changes in ride quality or handling, it is essential to have the suspension checked to ensure safe driving conditions.
Brake System Concerns
Braking issues are another area where Smart Forfour owners may encounter problems. Common complaints include squeaking brakes, reduced braking performance, and premature wear of brake pads and discs. These issues can compromise safety and should be addressed immediately.
Routine brake inspections are essential to ensure that all components are functioning correctly. If you hear unusual noises when braking or feel a loss of stopping power, it is crucial to have the brakes examined by a professional. Regular maintenance can help extend the life of brake components and ensure optimal performance.
Interior and Comfort Features
While not as critical as mechanical issues, problems with interior features can affect the overall ownership experience of the Smart Forfour. Owners have reported issues with the air conditioning system, infotainment unit, and various interior fittings. These problems can lead to discomfort and frustration during daily use.
Regular maintenance of the air conditioning system can help prevent issues such as poor cooling performance. Additionally, keeping an eye on the infotainment system for software updates can help improve functionality. If any interior components become loose or damaged, addressing these issues promptly can enhance the vehicle’s comfort and usability.
Frequently asked questions
What are the most common issues with the Smart Forfour?
Common issues with the Smart Forfour include electrical problems, gearbox issues, and suspension wear. Owners have also reported problems with the air conditioning and engine performance.
How reliable is the Smart Forfour?
The Smart Forfour generally has a mixed reliability record. While some owners report few problems, others have experienced significant issues, particularly with the transmission and electrical systems.
Are there any known electrical problems with the Smart Forfour?
Yes, electrical problems are quite common in the Smart Forfour. Issues can range from faulty wiring to problems with the dashboard display and central locking system.
What should I check before buying a used Smart Forfour?
Before buying a used Smart Forfour, check for service history, any signs of electrical faults, and the condition of the suspension. It's also wise to take a test drive to assess the gearbox and engine performance.
Is the Smart Forfour expensive to maintain?
Maintenance costs for the Smart Forfour can vary, but some owners find that parts can be pricier than expected. Regular servicing is essential to keep it running smoothly and to avoid costly repairs.
What are the signs of gearbox problems in the Smart Forfour?
Signs of gearbox problems include difficulty shifting gears, unusual noises when changing gears, and warning lights on the dashboard. If you notice these issues, it is advisable to have the vehicle inspected by a professional.
How can I prevent common problems with the Smart Forfour?
Regular maintenance, including timely oil changes and inspections, can help prevent common problems. Additionally, addressing any warning signs promptly can prevent minor issues from becoming major repairs.
Got a Smart Forfour reg?
Free profile in seconds. Full report £4.99.
Free profile. No signup. Powered by DVLA and DVSA.
Sources
DVSA MOT History, Honest John reliability index, Parkers owner reviews, WhatCar reliability survey, UK Government MOT failure data.